Photography and Art

Tuesday, May 6, 2008

Photog Discovery of the Week

This is a special month in Toronto. The Contact photo festival runs throughout the month of May and many galleries are exhibiting some wonderful images. In addition, several public spaces, including Pearson Airport, the concrete supports of the Gardiner Expressway and the Brookfield (formerly BCE) Place are featuring photo art.

I was wandering down Queen Street West on the look-out for photo exhibits when I discovered a new gallery, The Lausberg Contemporary, showing works by David Burdeny. The show is called Horizons and it consists of stunning, stark landscapes largely from Greenland and Antarctica. The works are mainly panoramas, but the quality of light is absolutely eerie. There is an amazing sense of stillness and grandeur about these works that I've not seen before in images of the Antarctic (a destination that has become a bit of a fad lately).



According to the exhibit blurb, David Burdeny has used long and repeated exposures to achieve the effects he displays in his images. No matter how he does it, the compositions are superb and the mood that he conveys is bittersweet, with beauty and peace overlaid with brooding and foreboding. The small thumbnail doesn't quite do justice to these large works, but you can sort of get an idea of the quality of these images.

If you are in the Toronto area, I would encourage you to get out this month and soak up the Contact exhibits.

Monday, April 14, 2008

Photog Discovery of the Week

This week, I'm recommending a photographer from Italy called Antonio Manno.


A Hand on Music (c) Antonio Manno

Even though Antonio has a web site, it is written in flash and is fairly difficult to navigate. I find his Pbase galleries easier to view and that's where the above link points.

Antonio specializes in digital black and white photography and I particularly like his images of jazz musicians. His command of lighting is superb and he has a knack for bringing out the raw emotion in the subject matter. It is obvious from these images that Antonio is passionate about jazz and jazz musicians.

It isn't easy photographing jazz musicians. Usually light levels are low and they have this annoying habit of moving to the music during their solos. I know, I've tried with mixed success. Every photo in this gallery has wonderful lighting - I wish I knew how he does it.

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Sigma DP1

There hasn't been a lot of buzz about exciting new cameras since the introduction of the Nikon D3, so it was nice to see that the Sigma DP1 was shipping and reviews were popping up all over the web.

For the uninitiated, there has been a quest among camera bloggers for a small camera that combines the photo quality of a DSLR with the portability of a point and shoot. Up until the introduction of the DP1, we've had some promising contenders (e.g. the Canon G9, Ricoh R8), but they have all used small sensors and suffered from horrendous noise levels at ISO 400 and up. Just as they used to say "there's no substitute for cubic inches" in the car game, there is no substitute for pixel size in the camera game. The larger the pixels, the higher the signal to noise ratio. Jim, ya canna break the laws of physics, laws of physics.

Along comes the Sigma DP1, a very exciting camera that offers a large (APS-C) sensor in a very small body. It also has a wide-angle lens, can shoot raw and offers manual control over all aspects of photography. It was introduced 18 months ago and only started shipping in quantity this month, so the wait was long. Was it worth it? Here are some of the early reviews:


After reading the reviews, I'm very tempted to buy one, but probably won't. Here are the pros and cons:

  • Pros
    • large APS-C sensor
    • Foveon sensor
    • high image quality/low noise
    • Good lens quality
    • Produces raw images
    • Simple user interface with good manual control
  • Cons
    • Auto focus delay
    • No zoom lens
    • Not yet supported by Adobe raw processing
    • Expensive
    • Poor quality built-in flash
    • Viewfinder is an extra cost add-on

To be a good walk-around portable camera and be able to capture the moment, a zoom lens and fast autofocus are really important. Ideally, I'd like a DP1 with a 3x zoom (preferably with a manual zoom ring), a built-in viewfinder and the auto-focus performance of a DSLR.

I think the DP1 falls into the "close, but no cigar" category. The reviews all praise Sigma for its pioneering spirit, but I'd be very surprised if this camera becomes a hit with the prosumer market.

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

New Versions of Kodak Plug-ins

It's nice that the hot news of the week is all about useful stuff, like new software, not the usual news about stuffing more pixels onto a tiny point and shoot sensor.

Kodak has announced upgrades to its suite of Photoshop plug-ins. There are four plug-ins:

  • Gem Pro - for noise and grain reduction. I've used Gem in the past and it was quite inferior to Noise Ninja, but I'm game to download a free trial and look at it again.
  • Gem Airbrush - a tool for portait photographers aimed at smoothing skin imperfections.
  • ROC -- for restoring colour balance in old photos or slides where fading has occured. I sure wish I'd had this when I'd worked on some 50 year-old slides of Kenya for a friend last month.
  • SHO - a contrast and exposure tool that claims to reveal details in highlights and shadows.

I'm going to download the free trials this week and give 'em a test drive.

New Version of Lightroom and Aperture

Competition is a wonderful thing. Apple just announced version 2.1 of Aperture with a new plug-in feature and back comes Adobe with the announcement of the Lightroom 2.0 beta program.

Ian Lyons has already created a very good tutorial to the new Lightroom 2.0 beta here. Here are my early thoughts on the beta:
  • Lightroom 2.0 will support 64 bit operating systems. This is great news - we no longer have to be memory constrained. Now I can look forward to the joy of upgrading to Vista 64 bit, buying more memory and wrestling with all my drivers again.
  • The new beta is very buggy and not recommended for production use. There is no compatibility yet with 1.3.1 catalogs.
  • There are lots of general UI tweaks that will be nice for long-time users. The improvements to collections and filters are very nice.
  • I'm very happy about the improvement in interoperability between Lightroom and Photoshop. You can now open a Lightroom image as an object in Photoshop without having to convert it to a TIFF file.
  • The exciting part of the Aperture announcement was the availability of a plug-in architecture along with commitments from folks like Noise Ninja to make their products available inside Aperture. Apple announced the first Aperture plug-in, a dodge and burn module.
  • Sadly, Adobe missed the point of the Aperture announcement. They did announce the inclusion of a very powerful dodge and burn module within Lightroom 2.0, but there was no announcement of a plug-in architecture, so sadly there won't be any plug-ins for Lightroom 2.0 in the near future.

I think there will be enough in this release to justify the inevitable upgrade cost, but the lack of a plug-in architecture will really have a lot of people, especially Mac users, scratching their heads and wondering if Lightroom was the right horse to back. I know if Aperture was available on Vista, I'd be downloading the trial version as we speak.

Monday, March 31, 2008

Is it the Camera or the Photographer?

There is a nice little tempest in a teapot going on right now between Ken Rockwell and Michael Reichmann. Ken wrote an article here called Your Camera Doesn't Matter where he pointed out that cameras don't make good photographs - people do. A good photographer can make great photos with primitive gear and bad photographers can make terrible snaps with great cameras.

Michael Reichmann, for some unexplained reason, rose to the bait and wrote this comeback called Your Camera Does Matter where he states that artists are very fussy over their gear and choose cameras that enhance their work.

Who is right?

I'm going to side with Ken Rockwell because I think Michael misses the point of Ken's article. Ken's web site is aimed primarily at people like me -- enthusiastic amateur photographers. His thesis, even though not explicitely stated, was that the average amateur photographer would improve their photographs by working harder at their craft (either by taking lots of pics or by taking seminars and joining camera clubs) than they would by investing in lots of advanced gear.

Michael responded by saying that advanced photo equipment is important to artists. While that may be true, that totally misses the enthusiastic amateur audience who read Ken Rockwell's daily blog. Ken is saying to us, his audience, that we should take more pictures, become more creative and not sweat the gear so much.

There is empirical evidence to back up Ken's advice. If you go to one of my favourite photo cruising sites, pbase.com, and do a search by camera, you'll see that pbase.com has photos taken by every conceivable type of camera, everything from Canon to Zunow. There is some segmentation. If you look at random photos taken with point and shoot cameras, you'll see a predominance of family snapshots.

However, if you look at the photos taken by enthusiastic amateurs, who tend to own digital SLR's, you'll see very little correlation between the price of the camera and the quality of the photography.

Here are some random good galleries taken by low-end DSLR's:

Trains in the French Alps
Composition and Texture

Without picking on anyone, have a look at the Canon 1Ds Mark III random gallery and you'll see many snapshots that don't demonstrate much command of the art.

I've used many cameras and they are nearly all capable of generating good work. However, Michael does have a point (shared by Ken) that better equipment makes it easier to produce good work, all things being equal. But, you have to have talent and ability in order to reach the full potential offered by your camera.

Let me close with a golf analogy, because I think the golf mindset and the camera buff mindset are very similar. Most amateur golfers spend a small fortune on equipment, but very few can break 100. The conventional advice is that a dollar spent on lessons will outweigh money spent on equipment, but the lure of the marketing message is impossible to resist and golfers opt to buy the latest driver or yet another putter. The new equipment rarely, if every, makes a difference and most golfers have a stack of equipment in the garage that came and went, failing to deliver on the manufacturer's promise.

Camera equipment is kind of like that. Amateur photographers will likely compose and take the same shot, regardless of whether it is with a Canon Rebel or the latest 21 megapixel 1Ds. Yes, there will be a difference in resolution, but the lighting, composition and subject matter will still reflect the talent of the amateur photographer. It won't look any better at 21 megapixels if it doesn't already look good at 6. The lesson here is to find a way to take better photographs by improving your skills, before upgrading your camera equipment.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Spring Training, Phoenix Arizona

This past week-end, I flew down to visit my brother and his family who live just outside Phoenix Arizona. We had a great time and played a little golf and enjoyed each other's company. On Sunday, we went to the Oakland A's/Texas Ranger spring training baseball game. The ball game was mildly interesting, but the fans were just a riot. I spent most of the game photographing the people in the stands. Here's a selection.