I work in an exciting area of Toronto near the Queen Street West art gallery district. It doesn't always work out, but I try to get out for a walk every day and usually carry a camera of some sort. There is a lot of art on the walls of buildings in this neighbourhood and I've been taking photos of some of my favourite works. I hope you enjoy them as much as I do...
Photography and Art
Wednesday, March 19, 2008
Friday, March 7, 2008
The Third Dimension Part II
It's funny that once an idea grabs you, evidence of it appears everywhere. Even though I've read tons of photo "how-to" books, none of them has talked about visualizing your photograph in three dimensions, yet some artists just naturally do this.
Here's a case in point. Today, I saw a cool exhibit by a young Montreal artist called Jessica Auer. Jessica won the Roloff Beny prize at Concordia University in 2006 and used the funds to travel the world, adding images to her "Re-creational Spaces" project.
These images are large, vibrant C-color prints that depict man's impact on tourist areas such as Las Vegas, Machu Picchu and Niagara Falls. These are non-judgmental photographs that challenge the viewer to make up their own minds as to the effect of man's intrusion on nature. Think of it as Burtynsky for the tourist trade. Funnily enough, the images are on display at the Toronto Imageworks Gallery (owned by Ed Burtynsky) right now.
Here's a sample image (the size obviously doesn't do it justice)

As you can see, the artist has created a wonderful sense of depth with this composition. The choice of vantage point puts all the lines on the diagonal, leading the eye from the foreground to the background.
Contrast this with many of my images that tend to have lots of parallel lines across the image, leading to a lack of three dimensionality.
The only thing I didn't like about this exhibit was the choice of C-print as the medium. I just find C-prints to be very plasticky and not a natural photography medium at all. Yes, the colour gamut is wonderful and yes, you can print some truly large photos on this medium, but the photos come out looking like they should be mounted on the wall at MacDonalds'. They have that feeling that they would stand up to spilled Coke and a good mopping. These prints were lovely, but could have better presented.
Here's a case in point. Today, I saw a cool exhibit by a young Montreal artist called Jessica Auer. Jessica won the Roloff Beny prize at Concordia University in 2006 and used the funds to travel the world, adding images to her "Re-creational Spaces" project.
These images are large, vibrant C-color prints that depict man's impact on tourist areas such as Las Vegas, Machu Picchu and Niagara Falls. These are non-judgmental photographs that challenge the viewer to make up their own minds as to the effect of man's intrusion on nature. Think of it as Burtynsky for the tourist trade. Funnily enough, the images are on display at the Toronto Imageworks Gallery (owned by Ed Burtynsky) right now.
Here's a sample image (the size obviously doesn't do it justice)

As you can see, the artist has created a wonderful sense of depth with this composition. The choice of vantage point puts all the lines on the diagonal, leading the eye from the foreground to the background.
Contrast this with many of my images that tend to have lots of parallel lines across the image, leading to a lack of three dimensionality.
The only thing I didn't like about this exhibit was the choice of C-print as the medium. I just find C-prints to be very plasticky and not a natural photography medium at all. Yes, the colour gamut is wonderful and yes, you can print some truly large photos on this medium, but the photos come out looking like they should be mounted on the wall at MacDonalds'. They have that feeling that they would stand up to spilled Coke and a good mopping. These prints were lovely, but could have better presented.
Thursday, March 6, 2008
The Third Dimension
Today, I went for a walk at noon hour and dropped in at the Stephen Bulger Gallery on Queen West here in Toronto. The current exhibit is by a wonderful Canadian photographer called Larry Towell.
Towell earned his stripes as a photo journalist, travelling the world to document the dispossessed. Wearying of the continual wars and general trampling of human rights around the world, he moved to Lambton County in south-western Ontario, bought a 75 acre farm and started raising crops.
His current photo exhibition is entitled "The World from My Front Porch", a huge departure from photographing worldwide human disasters and hardship. The photos are traditional black and white prints, 16x20 or larger, depicting Towell's family and pets in and around their farm. The scenes are pastoral, the mood is tranquil and the images are absolutely fabulous.
I first saw the photos in a newspaper article, then on the web, but I was not at all prepared for the impact that these photos have in person. The thing that strikes you when you stand in front of each image is the powerful depth of the composition. It's almost as if viewers were armed with 3D glasses at the front door of the gallery. There is something about each one of them that creates a powerful suction that pulls your eyeballs out of their sockets and into the image. Part of it is the quality of the prints themselves. These are traditional gelatin silver prints and the tonality of the images is just a thing of beauty. But, there is more to it than that. Each image is constructed so that the scene is three dimensional. There are cues to the eye and the brain everywhere, like dirt roads going into the background, a porch littered with trikes and toys leading to the subject, a boy in the foreground painting a picture of a truck in the background.
Towell has this amazing gift to see things in three dimensions and arrange the elements of the image to convey his vision. Here's an example. In the photo, you see three boys standing on a dirt road. The road recedes into the background. But, the boys are not arranged in a row - they are standing one behind another, all in focus. As a result, the image takes on this wonderful third dimension from the front boy, through to the middle, the back and then on down the road.
It reminds me of one of those optical illusions that were all the rage years ago, where at first you see a random pattern of coloured dots, but if you stare at the photo for long enough, you start to see a 3D image emerge. I get the same feeling as I stare at one of Towell's works. At first, you see a nicely composed black and white image with some handsome children or a pretty wife. Then, the image slowly resolves itself and the third dimension starts to appear. The photo seems to extend backwards into the wall.
This has given me lots to think about indeed. I look at my images and I see a lot of two dimensional works. In fact, when I take a photo, I tend to visualize the result in two-dimensional space. I compose the objects in the photo using guidelines like the rule of thirds that arrange them in a pleasing way along the x and y axis.
Now, I'm going to have to engage with the third dimension. I'm going to have to look for cues that place objects in relation to one another on the z axis, extending back away from the camera. The choice of lens probably factors into this as well. My guess would be that Towell uses telephoto lenses to compress the image and stress the depth of the scene. This calls for some experimentation!
Towell earned his stripes as a photo journalist, travelling the world to document the dispossessed. Wearying of the continual wars and general trampling of human rights around the world, he moved to Lambton County in south-western Ontario, bought a 75 acre farm and started raising crops.
His current photo exhibition is entitled "The World from My Front Porch", a huge departure from photographing worldwide human disasters and hardship. The photos are traditional black and white prints, 16x20 or larger, depicting Towell's family and pets in and around their farm. The scenes are pastoral, the mood is tranquil and the images are absolutely fabulous.
I first saw the photos in a newspaper article, then on the web, but I was not at all prepared for the impact that these photos have in person. The thing that strikes you when you stand in front of each image is the powerful depth of the composition. It's almost as if viewers were armed with 3D glasses at the front door of the gallery. There is something about each one of them that creates a powerful suction that pulls your eyeballs out of their sockets and into the image. Part of it is the quality of the prints themselves. These are traditional gelatin silver prints and the tonality of the images is just a thing of beauty. But, there is more to it than that. Each image is constructed so that the scene is three dimensional. There are cues to the eye and the brain everywhere, like dirt roads going into the background, a porch littered with trikes and toys leading to the subject, a boy in the foreground painting a picture of a truck in the background.
Towell has this amazing gift to see things in three dimensions and arrange the elements of the image to convey his vision. Here's an example. In the photo, you see three boys standing on a dirt road. The road recedes into the background. But, the boys are not arranged in a row - they are standing one behind another, all in focus. As a result, the image takes on this wonderful third dimension from the front boy, through to the middle, the back and then on down the road.
It reminds me of one of those optical illusions that were all the rage years ago, where at first you see a random pattern of coloured dots, but if you stare at the photo for long enough, you start to see a 3D image emerge. I get the same feeling as I stare at one of Towell's works. At first, you see a nicely composed black and white image with some handsome children or a pretty wife. Then, the image slowly resolves itself and the third dimension starts to appear. The photo seems to extend backwards into the wall.
This has given me lots to think about indeed. I look at my images and I see a lot of two dimensional works. In fact, when I take a photo, I tend to visualize the result in two-dimensional space. I compose the objects in the photo using guidelines like the rule of thirds that arrange them in a pleasing way along the x and y axis.
Now, I'm going to have to engage with the third dimension. I'm going to have to look for cues that place objects in relation to one another on the z axis, extending back away from the camera. The choice of lens probably factors into this as well. My guess would be that Towell uses telephoto lenses to compress the image and stress the depth of the scene. This calls for some experimentation!
Wednesday, February 13, 2008
Commentary on New Photo Fine Art Papers
A while back, I wrote a post on the number of fibre-based fine art papers being released by manufacturers such as Hahnemmuhle and Ilford. Last night, I did some printing using a brand new box of Ilford Galerie Gold Fibre Silk. I had high expectations. Michael Reichmann had reviewed this paper here and given it two thumbs up, so I eagerly unpacked the box of letter-sized paper and threw a sheet in my printer (an Epson R1800). I downloaded the profile from the Ilford web site and printed this picture:

I use this image a lot for printer tests. It has three things that are useful in evaluating prints:
After re-reading Michael's article, the words "your mileage may vary" resonated with me and I decided to examine my motivations for choosing fine art paper to see if I can sort out why I had such a negative reaction to this paper.
First of all, I have no background in traditional black and white photography. While I've been taking pictures for years, I only really got interested in photography when it intersected with my other passion: computers. I don't get all misty-eyed when people talk about the look and feel of old black and white photos. In fact, I find the whole aura around silver gelatin on fibre (basically silver Jello on cardboard) rather baffling. Cotton rag papers seem much better to me - they handle better and have a nice texture. If you're interested in delving further into the history of photo papers, here's the Wikipedia article.
Second, my personal style seems to be evolving towards a gentle, pastel-rich type of image. Here's an example of a photo that typifies the look that I like right now:

This is a print that borders on magic realism. It reminds me of some of Ken Danby's work and I like the subtlety of the colours in the water and sky as well as the way the paddle boat seems to transcend reality. In short, I was delighted when this came off the printer.
Given my current personal style, here are the criteria that I've decided to look for in fine art paper. Remember, your mileage may vary!
Cotton Rag, no optical brighteners

I use this image a lot for printer tests. It has three things that are useful in evaluating prints:
- the sky has some very delicate highlights, especially the top left quartile, where it is easy to lose highlight detail and have a big white blob instead.
- The trees on the left and right of the photo are very dark and it is easy to lose shadow detail and have two black blobs.
- The colours in the sky and the water contain lots of subtle shades of red and a colour cast is very easy to spot.
After re-reading Michael's article, the words "your mileage may vary" resonated with me and I decided to examine my motivations for choosing fine art paper to see if I can sort out why I had such a negative reaction to this paper.
First of all, I have no background in traditional black and white photography. While I've been taking pictures for years, I only really got interested in photography when it intersected with my other passion: computers. I don't get all misty-eyed when people talk about the look and feel of old black and white photos. In fact, I find the whole aura around silver gelatin on fibre (basically silver Jello on cardboard) rather baffling. Cotton rag papers seem much better to me - they handle better and have a nice texture. If you're interested in delving further into the history of photo papers, here's the Wikipedia article.
Second, my personal style seems to be evolving towards a gentle, pastel-rich type of image. Here's an example of a photo that typifies the look that I like right now:

This is a print that borders on magic realism. It reminds me of some of Ken Danby's work and I like the subtlety of the colours in the water and sky as well as the way the paddle boat seems to transcend reality. In short, I was delighted when this came off the printer.
Given my current personal style, here are the criteria that I've decided to look for in fine art paper. Remember, your mileage may vary!
- Lifespan: I've had bad experiences with fading dye inks on RC papers and don't want to go there again. I'd like to think that my art is going to outlive me.
- Colour accuracy and ability to differentiate between subtle colour differences. I don't have the equipment or know-how to do my own profiles, so I use manufacturer's profiles and depend on them to be accurate.
- Esthetics: I love paper that feels good to the touch, looks good in a frame and gives people the impression that I cared enough about my work to print it on a fine art paper.
- Price: given two papers of equal attractiveness and functionality, the cheapest will win out.
- High Dmax: the ability to print the blackest blacks is useful to people whose style features high contrast. Right now, that isn't me, so I rank high Dmax last in the list.
- Papers based on cotton rag with no or minimal optical brighteners
- Papers that are either based on wood fibre (with the potential to contain harmful lignin), or contain optical brighteners or both.
Cotton Rag, no optical brighteners
- Moab Somerset Photo (mould-made, no OBA's, claimed dMax 1.75)
- Moab Somerset Enhanced Velvet 225 (cotton, minimal OBA's)
- Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Pearl 320 (cotton, OBA-free)
- Moab Colorado Fiber Satine or Gloss 245 (alpha-cellulose base, OBA's, claimed dMax of 2.4
- Ilford Galerie Gold Fibre Silk 310 (alpha-cellulose base, OBA's, baryta coated)
- Harman Photo Gloss FB AI (alpha-cellulose base, baryta-coated)
- Hahnemuhle FineArt Baryta 325 (alpha-cellulose base, baryta-coated)
- Hahnemuhle FineArt Pearl 285 (base not specified, contains OBA's)
- Hahnemuhle Photo Rag Satin 310 (cotton, OBA's)
Update on Tony Ray-Jones
Just to lay this saga to rest, the print was delivered a couple of weeks ago and it is beautiful. We now have a lovely black and white print hanging on the wall that actually looks like a fine art photograph.
Monday, January 21, 2008
Update on the Tony Ray-Jones Print Saga
I'm very pleased to say that I got a great response from the Science and Society Picture Library:
Dear Huw,
You’re quite right, the scan currently on our print sales website is from an older, resin-coated print, whereas the other one is a more recent scan - of a fibre-based print - that was produced for 2004 museum publication ‘Tony Ray-Jones’ (Russell Roberts).
You’ll be notified by email when the new scan is uploaded, hopefully in the next day or so.
Regards,
Chris.
Chris Rowlin
Acquisitions Executive
SSPL
The new scan has in fact been loaded and you can see it here in all its glory. Note the shadow detail in the trees as one example of the superiority of this new print. I can't wait until I get the new print shipped out.
Thursday, January 17, 2008
Tony Ray-Jones

One of my favourite photographers is Tony Ray-Jones. He lived from 1941-1972, dying far too young from leukemia. I discovered Ray-Jones at a British retrospective show at the Stephen Bulger Gallery in Toronto.
For a number of years, Ray-Jones took some wonderful images of British life before the influence of America changed it forever. My wife and I liked a couple of images in the show very much, including the one on the left.
At Christmas-time, I was looking for a gift for my wife and thought seriously about plonking down a few thou' to purchase a print of the photograph from the Bulger gallery. The prints were produced from the original negs by the Ray-Jones estate and had the look of original prints, done in a traditional photo printing way.
Looking for a more reasonable solution, I started to poke around the web and found that the rights to the photograph were held by the UK Science and Society Picture Library. This library is a treasure-trove of pictures and well worth a few hours of on-line browsing. Not only that, but the library had an arrangement with a high quality printing house to reproduce its archive of photographs at fairly reasonable prices (around 50 pounds un-mounted). I ordered the Ray-Jones Glyndebourne 1967 photograph on high quality art paper and it was delivered the week before Christmas.
My wife was delighted with her gift, but I can't say I'm totally pleased with the quality of the reproduction. The print is much more contrasty than the gallery print that I saw and doesn't have the subtle grays that you see in the small web photo above. Interesting to note that the image on the printing house web site is very different from the one above (see below).

All the shadow detail has disappeared and the halftones are gone. Compare the tables in the two images and you'll see how horrible the printed version that we received is compared to the original.
I've sent off some e-mail enquiries to see why the reproduction is so bad and I'll update this post once I hear from the museum.
While it is nice to have an image on our wall that reflects the artist's flare for composition and captures a very amusing, very British scene, it would be better to have something that approximates the original photograph in quality.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)